ALBUM REVIEWI can remember the first time I heard Dave Matthews Band music. I willingly admit that I was almost instantly impressed, because it sounded like "real" music for a change. An actual band that was capable of creating some really good music.
I happen to own all of their studio recordings, and a few of the live discs too. They really are tremendous live, and highly recommended.
There are probably even a few tracks off of this album that could be turned into something special with a different arrangement live.
The problem I'm having with this latest outing is the choice of producer. Mark Batson should have been able to make a better album with the band he had to work with. I put a large portion of why I don't like this album on his shoulders.
I can understand not wanting to remain stagnant, and to try out new sounds. I just feel that this is either going to trick DMB into thinking they've done that, or it will sour them to the idea altogether, and that's bad for us either way.
Let's break things down track by (largely) banal track:
"Dreamgirl" starts off with the band wanting so badly to be Paul Simon. Queue the African choir, and let's get things started. This is actually a pretty good song, and a nice start. Even so, you can see the writing on the wall here. The lyrics aren't up to snuff, and they don't get better as we go along.
"Old Dirt Hill(Bring That Beat Back)" is a major sticking point for me. If you're going to have Carter Beauford to work with,
on a song that has the subtitle of bringing a beat back, don't you think that you should...I don't know...maybe have him PLAY A BEAT!? Instead, we get a weak song that's driven insipidly by drum machine pablum.
I've seen it happen time and again, but it never fails to disappoint me anyway. Here, the titular track "Stand Up" sounds like it's trying too hard to be something good. We've got the rhythm section working on this one, and the guitars and vocals are clueless throughout.
There's an intro for the song "American Baby" that's just some piano with gunshots and whatnot, and then we get to the song proper. This is one of the songs that I liked. The guitar is plucked almost with banjo-like tautness, and it's a well made song. It's not going to butter your toast for you, but it's not bad.
Ahh, the bad boy Dave song. "Smooth Rider" is a laid back song for the cool cat that Dave wishes he was. It's almost full of itself, but the southern swagger isn't overbearing. Musically, it's meant to be "stripped down" but seems a bit sparse instead.
"Everybody Wake Up(Our Finest Hour Arrives)" has a throw-away title. It might as well be a cereal box that has a huge star-shaped accent in bright red that says something like "Now with 25% more preachy goodness!!". Note to jam bands: If you're going to get political on a song, don't make it so hamfisted that it stinks enough to overwhelm the smell of "patchouli", ya got it?
Okay, so at least we're past that. Now, we can move on to hopefully a better song. What's this one called? Oh, it's "Out of My Hands". Frighteningly fitting though it may be, we have no control here, and this song is essentially a quieter version of the last one. Not only does it drip with the undertones of the Birkenstockian sentiment that "it's sucks you guys have to go fight in Iraq", but it has the nerve to recycle lyrics. Not from someone else's song. Not from an early DMB tune. Not from a song from the beginning of the album, but the crappy song RIGHT BEFORE THIS ONE!! C'mon already.
After that one-two punch of a fiasco, we deserve "Hello Again". It's lazy gait down a dirt road rhythm is sweet. The syncopation shakes off the blues of those last two songs, and we're treated to one of the songs that I enjoy from this album. This album is a great case of mp3 piracy, because you would do well to glean the wheat from the chaff here, and not plunk down your lucre for the whole disc. [I'm not even getting into the fact that the disc has been copy-protected, and tries to auto-install software on your PC to ensure this that has been known to crash some machines]
"Louisiana Bayou" sounds like something DMB should make a song about. Heck, make my day, listen to some ancient blues and zydeco and crank out a whole album of songs from your roots. This gets mired in some bad lyrics, and a fair-to-middlin' attempt at keeping it real. I do actually like the hooted accent on the end of each line in the chorus. It reminds me of an old Harry Bellafonte song called "Hold 'Em Joe".
"Stolen Away on 55th & 3rd" is a great song title, and it's not a bad song either. Aside from the metronome of another canned beat, the gentle sweetness of the vocals compliments the sax throughout.
We've already had the band trying to do it's best Paul Simon impersonation. Now, we get them catching a bad case of Sting syndrome. "You Might Die Trying" sounds to me like the band doing a parody of themselves in a world where we're all supposed to see all the subtleties of their genius and be humbled by it. How a laid back group of guys like this can be made to come off that way is beyond me, but give it a listen, and see if you can hear what I'm saying.
If you've read any of my other album reviews, then you know that I'm a sucker for softly sung lullaby type songs. "Steady As We Go" is just Dave's voice, and a piano taking center stage. It's got simple and sweet lyrics filled with hope, and I like this one.
It only takes us 14 songs of traveling to come across anything that really resembles what the Dave Matthews Band sound is. "Hunger For The Great Light" could easily have come off of any of their other albums. Here's the band firing on all cylinders together to make a good song. Sure, it's formulaic. The fact that blending great vocals with acoustic electric guitar and an underrated bassist, a genius drummer, and both a violin and sax player is a formula isn't a bad thing here.
Overall, I can't recommend this album. If you know someone who bought it, or has a copy, then have them make you one. If you download music, then do that, give them all a listen, and then see if you keep all the tracks in your collection. There are some worthwhile listens to be had. They're just few and far between, and what's left is just clumsy and lazy.
Rating = * out of 5 stars